The amateur short game is where rounds get rescued or buried. The pro from 50 yards averages around 1.5 strokes to get down. The 15-handicap amateur averages about 2.7. That gap — 1.2 strokes per opportunity, times 4-6 opportunities per round — is the single biggest place strokes leak in amateur golf.
The first decision — putt, chip, or pitch?
When the ball is off the green, the first question is always the same — can I putt it?
If the ground between you and the green is firm and short, putt. Putting is the lowest-variance short-game shot you have. A bad putt rolls 15 feet long. A bad chip can be a fat or a thin that costs you the up-and-down outright.
When to chip
A chip — low trajectory, more roll than carry — is correct when:
- You have firm ground and short grass between you and the flag
- You have at least 10-15 feet of green to land on before the slope changes
- There is no obstacle (bunker, rough) between you and the flag
When to pitch
A pitch — higher trajectory, more carry than roll — is correct when:
- You need to carry an obstacle (bunker, rough, hazard)
- The flag is tight to your side of the green
- You need the ball to stop quickly on a hard green
The bunker shot — explained simply
Greenside bunkers terrify amateurs. They should not. The mechanics are forgiving — open the face, hit the sand 2 inches behind the ball, accelerate through.
The mistake amateurs make is trying to lift the ball. The sand lifts the ball. Hit the sand, not the ball. Practice this shot until you can do it without thinking, and your average bunker score will drop by half a stroke.
The 4-foot rule
Whatever short-game shot you choose, judge it by where it leaves the next putt. The single most useful metric for amateurs around the green: did you leave yourself inside 4 feet?
Inside 4 feet, you are at PGA Tour-level make rates (60-70%). Outside 8 feet, you are at 30-40%. The difference between an okay chip and a great chip is whether your next putt is a tap-in.
Related reading
How to lower your golf handicap — by the numbers
A handicap drops when your average improves. Here are the four levers that actually move it for amateurs, ranked by impact.
Golf course management — playing smarter, not harder
Course management is the part of golf that has nothing to do with the swing. It is decisions — what club, what target, what miss to favour. For most amateurs, better decisions are worth more strokes than any swing change.
Want to actually measure what you just read about?
Log a round free